ASSEMBLY OF EXPERTS

The 'Assembly of Experts'^[1] (also 'Assembly of Experts of the Leadership') of Iran (Persian: مجلس خبرگان رهبری, ''Majles-e-Khobregan'' or ''Majles-e-Khebregan''), is a congressional body of 86 Mujtahids which elects the Supreme Leader and supervises his activities.
Members of the assembly are elected from a government-screened list of candidates by direct public vote to eight year terms. Current laws requires the assembly to meet for at least two days, twice annually.^[2][3]. The current chairman of the Assembly is Hashemi Rafsanjani, who was elected in September 2007. Rafsanjani to lead key Iran body, ''BBC'', 2007-09-04, accessed on 2007-09-04

Contents

Functions

History

Fourth Assembly

Third Assembly

Criticism

References and notes

External links

Functions

According to the Iranian Constitution, the assembly is in charge of supervising, dismissing and electing the Supreme Leader. In the event of his death, resignation or dismissal, the Experts shall take steps within the shortest possible time to appoint a new Leader.⁵ "Whenever the Leader becomes incapable of fulfilling his constitutional duties, or lobs one of the qualifications mentioned in" Constitution, "or it becomes known that he did not possess some of the qualifications initially, he will be dismissed."^[4] (The assembly has never dismissed a sitting Supreme Leader.)
The Experts are to review and consult among themselves concerning Islamic jurists possessing the qualifications of leadership. Constitutionally these criteria include "Islamic scholarship, justice, piety, right political and social perspicacity, prudence, courage, administrative facilities and adequate capability for leadership."^[5] In the event they find one of the jurists better versed in Islamic regulations, the subjects of the fiqh, or in political and social issues, or possessing general popularity or special prominence for any of the qualifications of leadership, they shall elect him as Supreme Leader. Otherwise, in the absence of such a candidate, the Experts shall elect and declare one of themselves as Supreme Leader.⁵
The assembly gathers every six months. Activities of the assembly include compiling a list of those eligible to become leader in the event of the current leader's death, resignation, or dismissal. This is done by the 107/109 commission. ^[6] Monitoring the current leader to make sure he continues to meet all the criteria listed in the constitution. This is done by the 111 commission. ^[7] Members of assembly report to this commission about the issues concerning the current leader, and the commission can then order an emergency meeting of the assembly. If the commission denies this, the members can ask the general assembly for a vote, and if most of the members of assembly decide, there will be an emergency meeting of the assembly for discussing the current leader. The meetings, meeting notes, and reports of the assembly are confidential and not made available to anyone outside the assembly, except for the sitting Supreme Leader.^[8]
The constitution does not specify requirements for members of the assembly, leaving the assembly itself to put limits on who may be a candidate. The assembly has passed laws to require all its members be experts in Fiqh (Islamic jurisprudence), ^[9] authorizing the Guardian Council to vet candidates for Ijtihad proficiency using written and oral examinations. This law is being challenged by the reformists, and their 2006 election campaign included changing this law to allow non-clerics into the assembly, and reforming the law that allows Guardian Council to vet candidates.^[10][11]
Currently, the average age of its members is over 60 years, which results in many mid-term elections.

History

The Assembly of Experts of the Leadership was first elected and convened in 1983. The first Assembly of Experts chose Ayatollah Montazeri as the successor to Supreme Leader Grand Ayatollah Khomeini. In 1989, however, they reversed their decision and dismissed him after Khomeini denounced him.^[12] Following the death of Ruhollah Khomeini on June 3, 1989, the Assembly of Experts chose Ali Khamenei to be his successor as Supreme Leader in what proved to be a smooth transition.^[13] Initially, a council of three members, "Ali Meshkini, Mousavi Ardabili and Ali Khamenei", were proposed for Leadership. After rejection of a Leadership Council by the assembly, and lack of votes for Grand Ayatollah Mohammad Reza Golpaygani, Khamenei became the Supreme Leader by two third of the votes.^[14]
The members of Assembly of Experts are elected every 8 years. It has therefore formed 4 terms, beginning in 1983, 1991 and 1999. The term formed in 2007, will exceptionally lasts ten years due to the "election aggregation" plan of Iran, put into place to allow the government to run one simultaneous election for both the Assembly of Experts and Parliament, thereby economizing election costs.
As all of their meetings and notes are strictly confidential, the assembly has never been known to challenge or otherwise publicly overseen any of the Supreme Leader's decisions.^[15]

Fourth Assembly

The election for the fourth assembly took place on 15 December 2006 and was convened on 19 February 2007. Ali Meshkini was re-elected as chairman. The changes in the presiding board from the 3rd assembly was the replacement of Mohammad Yazdi with Ebrahim Amini, who has retired, as the 2nd deputy chairman; and election of Hassan Rohani as provisionist.^[16]
Of particular note is the victory of pragmatist former President Ali Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani list, over hard-line candidates associated with President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad for positions in the 86-member Assembly of Experts. Rafsanjani lost out to Ahmadinejad in the 2005 election runoff for President. Mr. Rafsanjani won nearly twice as many votes as hard-liner Ayatollah Mohammad Taqi Mesbah Yazdi. Final results for the Assembly of Experts showed that more than 65 candidates close to Mr. Rafsanjani were elected. At 60 percent, voter turnout was much higher than in previous years.
The top 16 candidates in Tehran were announced as:
In July 2007 Meshkini died. Hashemi Rafsanjani was elected his successsor as chairman, beating Ayatollah Ahmad Jannati, an ally of President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, by 41 to 30 votes.

Third Assembly

The 3rd assembly was chaired by Ayatollah Ali Meshkini, deputied by Ali Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani, and Ayatollah Ebrahim Amini. The scribes were Ghorbanali Dorri-Najafabadi and Ahmad Khatami. The members according to each province were:^[17][18]

★ Tehran: # Ali Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani # Meshkini, Ali Akbar # Mohammad Mohammadi Rey-Shahri # Mohammad Imami Kashani # Mohammad Yazdi # Ahmad Jannati # Mohammad Reza Tavassoli # Ghorban Alli Dorri Najaf-Abadi # Mohammad Taghi Mesbah Yazdi # Majid Ansari # Asadi Khansari, Agha Baqer # Mohsen Kharrazi # Mohammad Mohammadi Gilani # Qomi, Mohsen # Reza Ostadi # Gholam Reza Rezvani ★ East Azarbaijan: # Mojtahed Shabestari, Mohsen # Seyed Reyhani, Seyed Abolfazl # Hashemzadeh Harisi, Hashem # Ahmadi, Ali # Oroumian, Ali ★ West Azarbaijan: # Ghaffari Gharebagh, Mir-Akbar # Pour-Mir Ghaffari, Seyed Mohsen # Ghoreishi, Mir-Ali Akbar ★ Isfahan: # Yasrebi, seyed Mehdi # Mazaheri Tehrani, Mirza Hossein # Hashemi, Seyed Esmail # Moqtadaie, Morteza # Mahdavi, Abolhasan ★ Ardabil: # Khalilzadeh, Bouck Agha ( died & Replaced By Seyyed Hatami, Mir Ebrahim) # Nourani Taqi Deizaj, Mostafa ★ Ilam: # Mohammadi, Rahim ★ Bushehr: # Abdonnabi Namazi

★ Chahar-Mahaal and Bakhtiari Province: # Haj Amini Najaf Abadi, Ebrahim ★ Khorasan: # Ebadi, Seyed Mehdi # Khazali, Abolghasem # Hashemi Shahrodi, Seyed Mahmod # Masomi, Ali Asqar # Ferdosi Pour, Esmail # Mehman Navaz, Habiboallah # Abbas Vaeze Tabasi # Alami, Hasan ★ Khouzestan: # Shafei, Seyed Ali # Mousavi, Seyed Mohammad Ali # Abbasi Fard, Mohammad Reza # Ali Fallahian # Abbas Kabi Nasab # Mohammadi Araghi, Mohsen ★ Zanjan: # Mousavi, Seyed Esmail ★ Semnan: # Alami, Mohammad Ali ★ Sistan va Balouchestan: # Hosseyni, Seyed Mojtaba # Madani, Mohammad Eshaq ★ Fars: # Dastqeib, Seyed Ali Asqar # Dastqeib, Seyed Ali Mohammad # Beheshti, Ahmad # Hosseyni, Seyed Mohammad Hossein # Imani, Asadollah ★ Qom: # Seyed Rohani, Agha Mehdi ★ Qazvin: # Mousavi Pour, Seyed Hasan # Sheikh Mohammadi, Ali ★ Kurdistan: # Sheikholleslami, Mohammad # Abdolqader Zahedi

★ Kermanshah: # Ahmadi, Zekrollah # Zarandi, Hossein ★ Kerman: # Seyed Ahmad Khatami # Hashemian, Mohammad # Mohammad Ali Movahedi ★ Kohgiluyeh and Buyer Ahmad: # Malek Hosseyni, Seyed Keramatollah ★ Golestan: # Noor Mofidi, Seyed Kazem # Taheri, Seyed Habibollah ★ Gilan: # Aminian, Mokhtar # Mahfoozi, Abbas # Ghorbani, Zeinolabedin # Taskhiri, Mohammad Ali ★ Lorestan: # Taheri Khorram Abadi, Seyed Hasan # Shahrokhi, Seyed Mohammad Taqi ★ Markazi: # Mohseni Garakani, Ahmad # Mir-Mohammadi, Seyed Abolfazl ★ Mazandaran: # Jabbari, Seyed Saber # Sadeq Ardeshir Larijani # Karimi Kalabi, Seyed Jafar # Rohani Rad, Hadi ★ Hormozgan: # Anvari, Mirza Mohammad ★ Hamedan: # Saberi Hamedani, Ahmad # Dabestani, Seyed Abolhasan ★ Yazd: # Khatam Yazdi, Abbas Agha

Criticism

Iran's assembly of experts has been subject to many criticisms with respect to its structure and function. The assembly for instance has never invited the leader to its meetings. Iran's leader has never been asked to offer a report of his performance over the last few decades. Instead the members of the assembly met with the leader in several occasions to have his advice. The assembly has very few meetings annually and the members mainly discuss subjects not related to their duties, as commenting on the president and government's policies and Iran's foreign policy. ^[19] Even some conservatives admitted the weakness of the Assembly's performance. In 2006, Mohammad Reza Bahonar, 7th parliament's first Vice Speaker said that the Experts Assembly should present a report on its performance so that the people realize the institution’s importance.^[20] As all of their meetings and notes are strictly confidential, the Assembly has never been known to challenge any of the Supreme Leader's decisions.

References and notes

1. http://www.nezam.org/
2. http://www.khobregan.ir/persian/ashnaee/07.htm
3. Robin Wright, ''The Last Great Revolution: Turmoil and Transformation in Iran'', Alfred A. Knopf, 2000
4. Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran Article 111
5. Constitution of Islamic Republic of Iran article 109
6. see discussion and assembly website, [1]
7. see discussion and assembly website [2]
8. [3]
9. http://www.khobregan.ir/persian/ashnaee/09.htm
10. http://www.aftabnews.ir/vdciryat1yazw.html
11. http://www.baztab.com/news/49011.php
12. http://www.irvl.net/Translation%20of%20Ayatollah%20Khomeini's%20Letter%20Dismissing%20Montazeri.htm
13. Background Note: Iran
14. [4][5]
15. "Iran Announces Second Extension of Voting," Reuters, Oct. 23, 1998.
16. [6][7][8]
17. Islamic Republic of Iran Members of Assembly of Experts
18. http://www.irvl.net/Assembly%20of%20Experts.htm
19. [9]
20. [10]

External links

★ Assembly of Experts - Official Wesbite

★ Assembly of Experts in the Constitution of Islamic Republic of Iran

★ Understanding Iran's Assembly of Experts from Durham University

★ Results of Assembly of Experts elections in 6 provinces

★ Results of Assembly of Experts elections in four provinces

★ Results of Assembly of Experts elections in some provinces