'Freedom' is narrowly defined by
Classic Liberals and
Neoliberals as the ability to act without restraint from the government, or more broadly defined as the ability to have access to particular resources from the government without constraint by
Social Liberals and most variants of
Socialism. Defined thusly, 'freedom' is a broad notion, not necessarily covering the same field as '
free will'.
The protection of interpersonal freedom can be the object of a social and political investigation, while the metaphysical foundation of inner freedom is a
philosophical and
psychological question. Both forms of freedom come together in each individual as the internal and external values mesh together in a dynamic compromise and power struggle; the society fighting for power in defining the values of individuals and the individual fighting for societal acceptance and respect in establishing one's own values in it.
In philosophy
An absence of restraint
The
philosopher Isaiah Berlin drew an important distinction between "freedom ''from''" (
negative freedom) and "freedom ''to''" (
positive freedom). For example, freedom ''from'' oppression and freedom ''to'' develop one's potential. Both these types of freedom are in fact reflected in the
Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
Freedom as the absence of restraint means unwilling to subjugate, lacking submission, or without forceful inequality. The achievement of this form of freedom depends upon a combination of the resistance of the individual (or group) and one's (their) environment; if one is in jail or even limited by a lack of resources, this person is free within their power and environment, but not free to defy reality. Natural laws restrict this form of freedom; for instance, no one is free to fly (though we may or may not be free to attempt to do so).
Isaiah Berlin appears to call this kind of freedom "negative freedom" - an absence of obstacles put in the way of my action (especially by other people). He distinguishes this from "positive freedom", which refers to my power to make choices leading to action.
Freedom has often been used a rallying cry for
revolution or
rebellion. For instance, the
Bible records the story of
Moses leading his people out of Egypt and its oppression (slavery), and into freedom to worship God. In his famous "
I Have a Dream" speech
Martin Luther King, Jr. quoted an old spiritual song sung by black American slaves: "''Free at last! Free at last! Thank God Almighty we are free at last!''"
Inner autonomy
In the context of internal control, freedom is also known as self-determination, individual sovereignty, or
autonomy.
Freedom can also signify inner autonomy, or mastery over one's inner condition. This has several possible significances:
[1]
★ the ability to act in accordance with the dictates of reason;
★ the ability to act in accordance with one's own true self or values;
★ the ability to act in accordance with universal values (such as the True and the Good); and
★ the ability to act independently of both the dictates of reason and the urges of desires, i.e. arbitrarily (autonomously).
In a play by
Hans Sachs, the Greek philosopher
Diogenes speaks to
Alexander the Great, saying: ''You are my servants' servant''. The philosopher has conquered fear, lust, and anger; Alexander still serves these masters. Though he has conquered the world without, he has not yet mastered the world within. This kind of mastery is dependent upon no one and nothing other than ourselves.
Richard Lovelace's poem echoes this experience:
:Stone walls do not a prison make
:Nor iron bars a cage
:Minds innocent and quiet take
:That for an hermitage
Notable
20th century individuals who have exemplified this form of freedom include
Nelson Mandela, Rabbi
Leo Baeck,
Gandhi,
Lech Wałęsa and
Václav Havel.
The French
philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau asserted that the condition of freedom was inherent to humanity, an inevitable facet of the possession of a soul and sapience, with the implication that all social interactions subsequent to birth imply a loss of freedom, voluntarily or involuntarily.
In those with spiritual beliefs, freedom may encompass the peaceful acceptance of reality. The theological question of freedom generally focuses on reconciling the experience or reality of inner freedom with the omnipotence of the divine.
Historical origins
The ''
ama-gi'', a Sumerian cuneiform word, is the earliest known written symbol representing the idea of freedom. Our English word "freedom" comes from an
Indo-European root that means "to love." Cognates of the English word "freedom" include the
Old High German word for "peace" and our English word "afraid" from a
Vulgar Latin word for breaking the peace.
Usage
★
Political freedom is the absence of political restraints, particularly with respect to
speech,
religious practice, and
the press.
★ Personal liberty can refer to not being in
prison (including not being a victim of
false imprisonment). It may also refer to the enjoyment of all of the privileges of
membership of a place or club (as in the honour, the
Freedom of the City),
financial freedom or
anarchism.
★ Economic freedom usually means the degree to which economic actors are unfettered by
governmental restrictions. Its most prominent advocates include
Austrian School,
Chicago School and
Supply-side economists. Free market advocates frame the issue of economic freedom as "the degree to which the
public sector interferes with the
private sector," and argue that the less a government acts to interfere with the economic freedom of businesses and individuals (such as through
taxation or
regulation), the healthier the economy will tend to be. Critics of capitalistic free markets equate Economic freedom with
economic power. The advocates of
mixed economies and
socialism contend that the public sector need not always be seen as an unwanted intruder on the economy, and that government action should not be seen as necessarily interfering or freedom-infringing. Nonetheless, some Socialists concede that some traditional freedoms will be curtailed when the dictatorship of the proletariat assumes power.
★ Freedom of choice, i.e.
free will.
★
Freedom of speech is similar to freedom of information, but refers to a general lack of such restrictions (on the creation, use, modification and dissemination of ideas) in a
society by the
government or those that hold power in that society.
★
Freedom of thought is also known as freedom of conscience and refers to the right of an individual to hold a particular thought, belief or viewpoint regardless of those held by others.
★
Psychological freedom, i.e. the ability to make the choice to not be afraid of failure in its most basic form.
★ Being not in any
relationship (be it a
romantic relationship or a
cooperative, for example), free to do what one wants, including starting a new relationship or having ''relationship tests'' (like one-night-stands, casual physical
intimacy, etc).
★ Freedom of education closely resembles
autodidacticism, which views modern schooling as a dismal system of captivity. Students have traditionally seen gaps in the school year as freedom from their oppression. This idea is not to be confused with
liberal education, as one may interpret them as opposites.
★
Software freedom or other
freedom of information (or ideas); i.e.: information (esp. software) being free of technological or (more commonly) legal restrictions on its use, modification, distribution and (less often restricted) creation. See also:
Free software,
Open source and
gratis software.
★ Leaving one's parents' home and
coming of age.
★ The absence of
interactions in
physics; for example,
asymptotic freedom discovered by
David Gross,
David Politzer, and
Frank Wilczek.
★ Political philosopher Gerald MacCallum designed the following concept of freedom, allowing for its 'fleshing out' into many different conceptions: "X is free/not free from Y to do/not do/become/not become Z."
★ To the Jews who believed Him
Jesus said "If you hold to my teaching, you are really my disciples. Then you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free."
★ Freedom from government and Church -
Christian anarchism.
References
1. Wolf, Susan, ''Freedom Within Reason''
Bibliography
★ Aristotle, ''The Nicomachean Ethics'', Book III.
★ Augustine (Saint), ''On Free Will''.
★ Hobbes, Thomas, ''Of Liberty and Necessity''.
★ Hume, David, ''An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding''.
★ Mill, John Stuart, ''On Liberty''.
★ Plato, ''The Republic''.
★ Schiller, Friedrich, ''Letters upon the Aesthetic Education of Man''. ISBN 1-4191-3003-X
★ Wolf, Susan, ''Freedom Within Reason'', Oxford: 1990.
Isaiah Berlin, ''Four Essays on Liberty''. London: Oxford University Press, 1969.
See also
★
Freedom (political)
★
Golden Freedom
★
Liberty
★
Christian libertarianism
★
Parametric determinism
★
List of indices of freedom
★
Leo Strauss
★
Inner peace
★
Self-ownership
External links
★
Freedom Fries Media
★
Sovereignty and Freedom
★
Psychological Freedom - Freedom from the inner shackles
★
Freedom of Will — an article by Rav Michael Laitman.
★
Freedom Theory
★
Free Will article from Catholic Encyclopedia