العربية
中国
Français
Deutsch
Ελληνική
हिन्दी
Italiano
日本語
Português
Русский
EspañolTHE CASE FOR PEACE
'''The Case for Peace: How The Arab-Israeli Conflict Can Be Resolved''' is the sequel to ''The Case for Israel'' by Alan Dershowitz, Felix Frankfurter Professor of Law at Harvard Law School. The book champions the two-state solution and has been endorsed by President Bill Clinton, who led Mideast peace talks during his term.
Dershowitz was originally planning to write ''The Case Against Israel's Enemies'', however, after the death of Yasser Arafat the author chose to focus on more positive and optimistic themes, believing that the death of the of the PA chairman has opened new doors to peace. Dershowitz argues that all reasonable people know that a final peace settlement will involve two states, the division of Jerusalem and a renunciation of violence.Inside Flap, The Case for Peace Dershowitz believes that the Palestinian state may be composed of multiple disjoint areas, because in today's world of high-speed internet and cheap travel, states do not require contiguity to be viable.[1] He asserts that Palestinans should not be offered more than what was during the Camp David negotiations of 2000, saying it would reward violence. He concentrates on the shared elements of the peace process that he says both mainstream Israelis and Palestinians agree on.
Clinton says the author "brings his exceptional skills as a legal and political thinker to this concise and compelling argument for Middle Eastern peace. The simple chord that resonates through the complex scenarios described in ''The Case for Peace'' is one of decency and respect - for Palestinians, for Israelis, and, ultimately, for humanity itself. With an eye toward shared benefits and lasting resolution, Dershowitz offers a pragmatic proposal rooted in the lessons of the past and the opportunities of the present. Hopeful and wise, the blueprint for stability presented in this book is among the best in recent years."[2]
Ariel Sharon, Prime Minister of Israel (during the book's publication) who famously led Israel's unilateral disengagement from the Gaza Strip and northern Samaria, credits Dershowitz for having "been on the forefront of making the case for Israel and against terrorism. ... He understands, as I do, how difficult it is to achieve peace with security. He confronts these difficulties with insight and with the benefit of years of experience."[2]
Stuart Eizenstat, former senior official in the Carter and Clinton administrations, applauded Dershowitz for his "brilliance" as he says he presented earlier in ''The Case for Israel''.[2]
Israeli writer and well-known advocate for the two-state solution Amos Oz praised the book for not being "based not on sentimentalist wishful thinking and not on dogmatic theorizing but on realism and empathy."[2]
Dennis Ross, former U.S. Envoy to the Middle East, encourages anyone who "believes in peace, even while having doubts about whether it can be achieved" to read the book.[2]
Michael D. Langan of ''The Boston Globe'' writes: "Dershowitz makes a compelling 'Case for Peace'...The author's advocacy skills are well-honed and incisive. In fact, one is reminded of the logical argumentation used by Thomas Aquinas in his Summa Theologica...: laying out basic questions for analysis, exploring arguments that appear reasonable, and concluding with an equivalent of Aquinas's famous 'I answer that . . .,' which gives the 'correct' answer.[7]
Publishers Weekly remarked that Dershowitz "bombards opponents with inflammatory charges based on sometimes tendentious readings of skimpily contextualized remarks..." It also stated that the book lacked "the judicious treatment these issues cry out for."[8]
David Bedein, the bureau chief of the Israel Resource News Agency, expressed disappointment that "Dershowitz has now adopted a strategy of 'if you can’t beat them, join them.'" Bedein criticizes several of Dershowitz's positions individually, giving each "error" its own section arguing that they are oblivious to reality. He feels the author's "failure to challenge questionable assumptions about the prospects for peace is deeply regrettable. By exaggerating the Palestinian leadership’s readiness to make peace, Dershowitz has granted credibility to those critics, many of them rank anti-Semites, who are desperate to blame the persistence of the conflict on Israel."[9]
Mark Lewis, writing for the New York Times Book Review, writes that "''The Case for Peace'' is faithful to the title: Dershowitz says Yasser Arafat's death makes peace possible, if the Palestinians accept a state based in Gaza and 'nearly all of the West Bank,' with a division of greater Jerusalem."[10] Lewis further writes:
University of Michigan student and managing editor of the ''The Michigan Israel Observer'', Yevgeny Shrago, says the author "has devoted a great deal of time, thought and analysis to the situation. In these thirteen chapters he approaches the problem evenhandedly. Dershowitz censures Israel when he feels it is necessary and seeks solutions, regardless of who is to blame. Each chapter opens with a series of quotations from notable figures involved in the Middle East peace process, and Dershowitz presents hard data to support his conclusions. He does not, however, shy away from a criticism of the leadership."[11] However, Shrago later writes: Shrago further comments "everything that he writes is important knowledge to have, but a book attempting to foster understanding is not the place to learn it."
1. Peace at Any Cost, Jewish Virtual Library
2. "Amazon.co.uk: ''The Case for Peace'': How the Arab-Israeli Conflict Can Be Resolved: Books: Alan M. Dershowitz", online posting on the website of Amazon.com, accessed January 5, 2007.
3. "Amazon.co.uk: ''The Case for Peace'': How the Arab-Israeli Conflict Can Be Resolved: Books: Alan M. Dershowitz", online posting on the website of Amazon.com, accessed January 5, 2007.
4. "Amazon.co.uk: ''The Case for Peace'': How the Arab-Israeli Conflict Can Be Resolved: Books: Alan M. Dershowitz", online posting on the website of Amazon.com, accessed January 5, 2007.
5. "Amazon.co.uk: ''The Case for Peace'': How the Arab-Israeli Conflict Can Be Resolved: Books: Alan M. Dershowitz", online posting on the website of Amazon.com, accessed January 5, 2007.
6. "Amazon.co.uk: ''The Case for Peace'': How the Arab-Israeli Conflict Can Be Resolved: Books: Alan M. Dershowitz", online posting on the website of Amazon.com, accessed January 5, 2007.
7. "Dershowitz makes a compelling 'Case for Peace'", Michael D. Langan, The Boston Globe November 15, 2005
8. Review of ''The Case for Peace'', Publishers Weekly
9. Alan Dershowitz’s View of Mid-East Peace, January 5, 2006
10. New York Times Book Review: Review of ''The Case for Peace''
11. Dershowitz Strikes Back, Michigan Israel Observer
★ Amazon Online Reader: ''The Case for Peace: How the Arab-Israeli Conflict Can be Resolved''
★ A Case Study in Hate and Intimidation - Chapter 16 of ''The Case For Peace'' PDF Format
★ ''The Case For Peace'': New York Times Book Review
★ ''The Case For Peace'': Boston Globe Book Review
★ "Famed attorney lays out plan for peace" Stephen Mark Dobbs, ''The Jewish News Weekly'', January 26, 2007
★ ''The Case For Peace'': Yale Israel Journal Review
★ Edward Mil Q. Salazar
★ The Case for Israel
★ Arab-Israeli conflict
Dershowitz was originally planning to write ''The Case Against Israel's Enemies'', however, after the death of Yasser Arafat the author chose to focus on more positive and optimistic themes, believing that the death of the of the PA chairman has opened new doors to peace. Dershowitz argues that all reasonable people know that a final peace settlement will involve two states, the division of Jerusalem and a renunciation of violence.Inside Flap, The Case for Peace Dershowitz believes that the Palestinian state may be composed of multiple disjoint areas, because in today's world of high-speed internet and cheap travel, states do not require contiguity to be viable.[1] He asserts that Palestinans should not be offered more than what was during the Camp David negotiations of 2000, saying it would reward violence. He concentrates on the shared elements of the peace process that he says both mainstream Israelis and Palestinians agree on.
| Contents |
| Reaction |
| Praise |
| Criticism |
| Mixed reaction |
| Notes |
| External links |
| Book excerpts |
| Book reviews |
| See also |
Reaction
Praise
Clinton says the author "brings his exceptional skills as a legal and political thinker to this concise and compelling argument for Middle Eastern peace. The simple chord that resonates through the complex scenarios described in ''The Case for Peace'' is one of decency and respect - for Palestinians, for Israelis, and, ultimately, for humanity itself. With an eye toward shared benefits and lasting resolution, Dershowitz offers a pragmatic proposal rooted in the lessons of the past and the opportunities of the present. Hopeful and wise, the blueprint for stability presented in this book is among the best in recent years."[2]
Ariel Sharon, Prime Minister of Israel (during the book's publication) who famously led Israel's unilateral disengagement from the Gaza Strip and northern Samaria, credits Dershowitz for having "been on the forefront of making the case for Israel and against terrorism. ... He understands, as I do, how difficult it is to achieve peace with security. He confronts these difficulties with insight and with the benefit of years of experience."[2]
Stuart Eizenstat, former senior official in the Carter and Clinton administrations, applauded Dershowitz for his "brilliance" as he says he presented earlier in ''The Case for Israel''.[2]
Israeli writer and well-known advocate for the two-state solution Amos Oz praised the book for not being "based not on sentimentalist wishful thinking and not on dogmatic theorizing but on realism and empathy."[2]
Dennis Ross, former U.S. Envoy to the Middle East, encourages anyone who "believes in peace, even while having doubts about whether it can be achieved" to read the book.[2]
Michael D. Langan of ''The Boston Globe'' writes: "Dershowitz makes a compelling 'Case for Peace'...The author's advocacy skills are well-honed and incisive. In fact, one is reminded of the logical argumentation used by Thomas Aquinas in his Summa Theologica...: laying out basic questions for analysis, exploring arguments that appear reasonable, and concluding with an equivalent of Aquinas's famous 'I answer that . . .,' which gives the 'correct' answer.[7]
Criticism
Publishers Weekly remarked that Dershowitz "bombards opponents with inflammatory charges based on sometimes tendentious readings of skimpily contextualized remarks..." It also stated that the book lacked "the judicious treatment these issues cry out for."[8]
David Bedein, the bureau chief of the Israel Resource News Agency, expressed disappointment that "Dershowitz has now adopted a strategy of 'if you can’t beat them, join them.'" Bedein criticizes several of Dershowitz's positions individually, giving each "error" its own section arguing that they are oblivious to reality. He feels the author's "failure to challenge questionable assumptions about the prospects for peace is deeply regrettable. By exaggerating the Palestinian leadership’s readiness to make peace, Dershowitz has granted credibility to those critics, many of them rank anti-Semites, who are desperate to blame the persistence of the conflict on Israel."[9]
Mixed reaction
Mark Lewis, writing for the New York Times Book Review, writes that "''The Case for Peace'' is faithful to the title: Dershowitz says Yasser Arafat's death makes peace possible, if the Palestinians accept a state based in Gaza and 'nearly all of the West Bank,' with a division of greater Jerusalem."[10] Lewis further writes:
University of Michigan student and managing editor of the ''The Michigan Israel Observer'', Yevgeny Shrago, says the author "has devoted a great deal of time, thought and analysis to the situation. In these thirteen chapters he approaches the problem evenhandedly. Dershowitz censures Israel when he feels it is necessary and seeks solutions, regardless of who is to blame. Each chapter opens with a series of quotations from notable figures involved in the Middle East peace process, and Dershowitz presents hard data to support his conclusions. He does not, however, shy away from a criticism of the leadership."[11] However, Shrago later writes: Shrago further comments "everything that he writes is important knowledge to have, but a book attempting to foster understanding is not the place to learn it."
Notes
1. Peace at Any Cost, Jewish Virtual Library
2. "Amazon.co.uk: ''The Case for Peace'': How the Arab-Israeli Conflict Can Be Resolved: Books: Alan M. Dershowitz", online posting on the website of Amazon.com, accessed January 5, 2007.
3. "Amazon.co.uk: ''The Case for Peace'': How the Arab-Israeli Conflict Can Be Resolved: Books: Alan M. Dershowitz", online posting on the website of Amazon.com, accessed January 5, 2007.
4. "Amazon.co.uk: ''The Case for Peace'': How the Arab-Israeli Conflict Can Be Resolved: Books: Alan M. Dershowitz", online posting on the website of Amazon.com, accessed January 5, 2007.
5. "Amazon.co.uk: ''The Case for Peace'': How the Arab-Israeli Conflict Can Be Resolved: Books: Alan M. Dershowitz", online posting on the website of Amazon.com, accessed January 5, 2007.
6. "Amazon.co.uk: ''The Case for Peace'': How the Arab-Israeli Conflict Can Be Resolved: Books: Alan M. Dershowitz", online posting on the website of Amazon.com, accessed January 5, 2007.
7. "Dershowitz makes a compelling 'Case for Peace'", Michael D. Langan, The Boston Globe November 15, 2005
8. Review of ''The Case for Peace'', Publishers Weekly
9. Alan Dershowitz’s View of Mid-East Peace, January 5, 2006
10. New York Times Book Review: Review of ''The Case for Peace''
11. Dershowitz Strikes Back, Michigan Israel Observer
External links
Book excerpts
★ Amazon Online Reader: ''The Case for Peace: How the Arab-Israeli Conflict Can be Resolved''
★ A Case Study in Hate and Intimidation - Chapter 16 of ''The Case For Peace'' PDF Format
Book reviews
★ ''The Case For Peace'': New York Times Book Review
★ ''The Case For Peace'': Boston Globe Book Review
★ "Famed attorney lays out plan for peace" Stephen Mark Dobbs, ''The Jewish News Weekly'', January 26, 2007
★ ''The Case For Peace'': Yale Israel Journal Review
See also
★ Edward Mil Q. Salazar
★ The Case for Israel
★ Arab-Israeli conflict
This article provided by Wikipedia. To edit the contents of this article, click here for original source.
psst.. try this: add to faves
